Posts Tagged ‘Muntazer al-Zaidi’

Iraqi shoe-thrower was beaten by security, says judge

December 20, 2008

• Chief investigator says journalist may be pardoned
• Doubts cast on apology as ‘shoe intifada’ spreads

Muntazer al-Zaidi could hardly have anticipated the extraordinary reaction when he hurled his shoes at George Bush on Sunday to protest at the invasion of Iraq. His “farewell kiss” to the US president has kept the previously unknown TV journalist in the centre of global attention – a hero across the Arab world and beyond.

Zaidi, who was wrestled to the ground by security men, was beaten on the face, investigating judge Dhia al-Kinani revealed in Baghdad yesterday. But claims that he has asked the Iraqi prime minister to forgive him for his “big ugly act” were immediately questioned by his brother.

Zaidi’s emergence as a role model for anti-American resistance was confirmed by the Iranian ayatollah Ahmad Jannati, who praised what he called the “shoe intifada [uprising]” at Tehran University, where demonstrations against the “Great Satan” have been routine for 30 years.

In a mosque in Baghdad’s Sadr City, Shia cleric Mohanad al-Moussawi told worshippers that “al-Zaidi’s life must be protected and he must be immediately, immediately, immediately released”. Sunni preachers issued similar calls.

In London, Media Workers Against the War presented a box of shoes and a letter – signatories included Tony Benn – to the US embassy, pointing out that the journalist was “guilty of nothing but expressing Iraqis’ legitimate and overwhelming opposition to the US-led occupation of their country.”

Kinani said Zaidi’s letter to prime minister Nouri al-Maliki could lead to a pardon rather than a two-year jail sentence, but Zaidi’s brother Dirgham insisted in an interview with al-Jazeera that any apology could only have been written “under pressure”.

If it is confirmed, Zaidi’s remorse may not be appreciated by supporters such as the Egyptian who offered to marry his 20-year-old daughter to Zaidi or the Palestinian from the West Bank town of Nablus who went further: pledging both a daughter and $30,000 for the Iraqi’s legal costs. A Bahraini admirer offered to buy him a luxury limousine.

It could also be a disappointment for the Saudi who reportedly said he would pay 10m riyals for the size 10 “freedom shoes.” Following the old adage that success has many fathers, cobblers all over the Middle East have claimed they manufactured the loafers though most footwear in Iraq is Chinese-made. The most convincing claim came from Turkey, where manufacturer Ramazan Baydan said he might change the name of the shoe, prosaically called Model 271, to the Bush Shoe or Bye-bye Bush model. “Thanks to Bush, orders are flying in like crazy,” he said. Ayatollah Jannati called for the shoes to be deposited in a museum in Iraq. But Judge al-Kinani revealed they had been destroyed by investigators trying to determine whether they contained explosives.

Copycat footwear hurling has apparently also begun elsewhere, with a Ukrainian nationalist, as yet unnamed, throwing his boots at an Odessa speaker arguing in favour of Nato expansion.

It has also been a busy week for the spinoff online game Sock and Awe, which lets players throw virtual brown loafers at Bush. The site says 46m cyber-shoes have struck the presidential head as of Friday afternoon.

George Bush Shoe-Thrower ‘Too Severely Beaten’ for Court Appearance

December 18, 2008

Iraqi journalist who threw his shoes at US president was not taken to court because it could ‘trigger anger’, alleges brother

by Peter Walker and agencies | Guardian,UK,  Dec 17, 2008

The brother of an Iraqi journalist who hurled his shoes at George Bush claimed today that the television reporter was too badly beaten to appear in court, as the speaker of Iraq’s parliament reportedly announced his resignation over the issue.Dargham al-Zaidi said he was told a judge had been to see his younger brother, Muntazer, at the jail where he has been held since throwing his shoes at the US president during a press conference in Baghdad on Sunday. The television reporter – whose actions have made him a star in the Arab world – called Bush a “dog” and said he was angry at the US occupation of his country.

[Iraqi journalist Muntazer al-Zaidi, who hurled shoes at US President George W. Bush. The journalist who has since become a star in the Arab world appeared before a judge on Wednesday, his brother said. (AFP/File)]Iraqi journalist Muntazer al-Zaidi, who hurled shoes at US President George W. Bush. The journalist who has since become a star in the Arab world appeared before a judge on Wednesday, his brother said. (AFP/File)

The family went to Baghdad’s central criminal court expecting a hearing, Dhargham said, but were told the investigative judge had been to the prison and they should return in eight days. “That means my brother was severely beaten and they fear that his appearance could trigger anger at the court,” he said.Iraqi officials have denied that Muntazar, a 29-year-old reporter for the private Al-Baghdadia TV station, has been injured. Under Iraq’s legal system a judge investigates an allegation before recommending whether to order a trial. Initial hearings are often conducted informally rather than in court.

According to Dargham, his brother suffered a broken arm and ribs, as well as injuries to an eye and a leg after being beaten by security officials, and was treated at the Ibn Sina hospital, in Baghdad’s heavily fortified Green Zone. Dargham said he did not know whether the injuries happened when Muntazer was being overpowered at the press conference or later.

The journalist faces possible trial under a clause in the Iraqi penal code outlawing “aggression against a president”. If convicted, he could be imprisoned for seven to 15 years. Dargham said he was told by the investigating judge that his brother “had co-operated well”, but had no other details.

During a press conference marking Bush’s farewell visit to Iraq as US president, Muntazer jumped up and shouted: “It is the farewell kiss, you dog”. He threw both his shoes at the US leader – a severe insult in the Arab world.

Iraq’s parliament erupted into chaos today as MPs debated Muntazer’s continued detention. An official in the office of the speaker, Mahmoud al-Mashhadani, said he had resigned after the row, although it was not clear why this had happened.

The US state department said yesterday it would condemn “unnecessary force” used against Muntazer, but it did not know whether any had occurred.

Bush’s press secretary, Dana Perino – who was sporting a bruise under her eye after being struck by a microphone stand during the melee – said the president held “no hard feelings” about the incident and accepted it was up to Iraq to decide on any punishment.